The only organization dedicated solely to helping state boards advance equity and excellence in public education.

Education Leaders Report   |   August 2015 — Volume 1, No. 2
Advancing School Discipline Reform


Exclusionary discipline practices such as suspensions and expulsion aim to create orderly, safe classrooms, but there is little evidence they actually work. Moreover, students of color and those with disabilities experience such school discipline more often than their peers. American Institutes for Research analysts Greta Colombi and David Osher explore the research on punitive school discipline and zero-tolerance policies, their effects on student achievement and engagement, and a range of more effective disciplinary strategies that should supplant them. “Punitive discipline has increasingly been used as a quick fix to what often is a chronic, long-term problem,” Colombi and Osher write, an approach that has created more problems. Zero-tolerance policies often do not improve school climate: Suspended students are more likely to struggle academically, drop out of school, commit violent crimes, and enter the juvenile justice system. State policymakers can advance school discipline reform and improve school climate, say Colombi and Osher. State boards of education can work with state agencies to develop policies and support practices that strengthen the data collection, analysis, and stakeholder collaboration needed for such reform.


Advancing School Discipline Reform




Related Content

Featured Items

American at a polling booth i

New Faces, Shifting Parties Mark 2026 Midterm Elections for Education Officials

Voters in nine states, three territories, and Washington, DC, decided 49 state board races.
Group of high school students throwing colorful confetti in the air, celebrating graduation on a sunny day i

States’ Role in Transforming High School: Evidence, Trends, and the Path Forward

High school sits at the intersection of everything states want for their young people, yet many young people say high school is not working for them. State leaders have numerous levers to incentivize high school transformation.
Super Girl i

States That Are Leaning into Math Improvement Share Their Lessons

Amid faltering K-12 performance in math, policymakers have marshalled a host of stakeholders to tackle math improvement.

Upcoming Events

From the States